Magazine article from our research archive:
|
|
A quagmire? Vietnam, Iraq & other analogies.
- Article from:
-
Commonweal
- Article date:
-
January 16, 2004
- Author:
-
|
Copyright informationCOPYRIGHT 2004 Commonweal Foundation. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan. All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)
|
As Americans contend with an increasingly dangerous and uncertain situation in Iraq, the language we use to debate our policy becomes more and more important. Vietnam-era phrases like "credibility gap," "quagmire," and "exit strategy" are now frequently heard. These terms serve as more than 1960s catch-words for analogizing the recent difficulties facing U.S. troops in Iraq with what happened in Vietnam. They reveal a governmental mindset that once mired this country in Vietnam and is at work in our current occupation of Iraq.
Not everyone has signed on to this lexicon. In commenting on the pundits' new passion for juxtaposing Vietnam with Iraq, one Vietnam veteran, Colin ...
Related newspaper, magazine, and journal articles:
|
Why Iraq is not like Vietnam.(OPINION)
The Christian Science Monitor;
August 27, 2003 ;
700+ words
......many dissimilarities between Vietnam and Iraq. * The Vietnam war was fought in rice paddies...000 Americans and 3 million Vietnamese. In Iraq, the American death toll...striking similarity between Vietnam and Iraq, namely the goals and strategy...
|
|
Some See Parallels Between Iraq, Vietnam
AP Online;
April 21, 2004 ;
685 words
......see the possibility of a Vietnam-style "quagmire" in Iraq. Says Powell, "We must...Mass., is calling the Iraq dilemma "Bush's Vietnam." There are no assurances...reconstruction aid for Iraq; post-conflict Vietnam didn't cost America a...
|
|
Bush draws parallels between Iraq, Vietnam.
Chicago Tribune (Chicago, IL);
August 22, 2007 ;
700+ words
......parallels between Iraq and Vietnam, Bush said: Then as...society. Bush used Vietnam as an example of what might happen in Iraq if U.S. forces were...S. involvement in Vietnam already have taken place in Iraq. We are already talking...
|
|
Iraq is not Vietnam; it's probably worse
The Record (Bergen County, NJ);
November 22, 2006 ;
700+ words
......Bergen County, NJ) 11-22-2006 Iraq is not Vietnam; it's probably worse TRUDY...comparison Let me start by saying Iraq is no Vietnam. The complex Iraqi situation...years. Spilling over Unlike Vietnam, the continuing Iraq war would be likely to spill...
|
|
Iraq more complex than Vietnam
Charleston Gazette;
November 24, 2006 ;
700+ words
......down to a real debate over Iraq, President Bush went to ... Vietnam. The symbolism is astonishing...Let me start by saying Iraq is no Vietnam. The complex Iraqi situation...lasted for 15 years. Unlike Vietnam, the continuing Iraq war would be likely to...
|
|
Iraq is not Vietnam; it could be an even bigger disaster.
Philadelphia Inquirer (Philadelphia, PA);
November 21, 2006 ;
700+ words
......down to a real debate over Iraq, President Bush went to ... Vietnam. The symbolism is astonishing...Let me start by saying Iraq is no Vietnam. The complex Iraqi situation...lasted for 15 years. Unlike Vietnam, the continuing Iraq war would be likely to...
|
|
Parallels drawn between Vietnam, the war in Iraq
Sun-Journal Lewiston, Me.;
August 19, 2006 ;
633 words
......ever correct diagnosis. In Iraq, as in Vietnam, we face a vicious insurgency...of the American public. In Iraq, as in Vietnam, we have failed to cut off the enemy from re-supply. In Iraq, as in Vietnam, we have had ever-shifting...
|
|
Vietnam echoes in Iraq A retired general considered an expert in...
Columbia Daily Tribune;
August 12, 2007 ;
700+ words
......and military leaders fail in Vietnam and Iraq? What has Iraq taught the U.S...McClatchy Newspapers reporter. Iraq and Vietnam, he said, are both products of...deaths." The flawed assumptions of Vietnam and Iraq are nearly mirror images of one...
|
|
Hagel's year in Vietnam shaped feelings on Iraq.
Omaha World-Herald (Omaha, NE);
January 21, 2007 ;
700+ words
......few similarities between Iraq and Vietnam. Calling Bush's new strategy...further, calling conditions in Iraq an absolute replay of Vietnam. Then, at a Senate hearing...very much at that time in Iraq, not unlike in Vietnam. When he sees combat footage...
|
|
COLUMN: Is Iraq the new Vietnam?
University Wire;
December 14, 2006 ;
700+ words
......sharp parallels is that neither Vietnam nor Iraq was the slightest threat to America...way the administrations work in Vietnam and Iraq. "I find the basic parallels...on an ideal like Communism in Vietnam, Iraq is fighting a civil war as the...
|
|
Iraq Is Iraq; Vietnam Was Vietnam
NPR All Things Considered;
January 26, 2007 ;
511 words
......Things Considered 01-26-2007 Iraq Is Iraq; Vietnam Was Vietnam Host: Michele NORRIS...comparisons between the wars in Iraq and Vietnam. He's not convinced they are at all alike. DINESH D'SOUZA: Iraq is not Vietnam and here's why. First, we had...
|
|
Iraq conflict 'worse' than Vietnam war.(News)
The Birmingham Post (England);
October 20, 2006 ;
626 words
......the situation in Iraq was more grave than Vietnam nearly 40 years ago...Coalition, said: Iraq is even worse than Vietnam. The US were able...country. He went on: Iraq is much more strategically important than Vietnam from the point of...
|
|
Iraq is another Vietnam
Oakland Tribune;
April 17, 2004 ;
634 words
......filling the air with cries of "Iraq is another Vietnam." In the syndrome-addled brains...down." The differences between Iraq and Vietnam are much starker than the similarities...that liberals can understand: Iraq is another Vietnam. Fallujah is another Tet. And...
|
|
Iraq isn't like Vietnam it's much worse
Deseret News (Salt Lake City);
October 9, 2005 ;
554 words
......activists that the war in Iraq is just like the Vietnam War, a misguided and...disagree. The war in Iraq is a lot worse. Vietnam had its problems, starting...military presence in Iraq continues, the more it makes even Vietnam look sane. Which brings...
|
|
Fed: Iraq could be Howard's Vietnam
AAP General News (Australia);
April 9, 2004 ;
700+ words
......sides of the Pacific between Iraq and Vietnam, which lasted 11 years and claimed...sees clear parallels between Vietnam and the Iraq war. "In both cases, you had...officer Neil James disagreed. "Iraq and Vietnam are quite different in a geographic...
|
See all results.
Or, try our
Advanced Search.
|