HighBeam Research - Newspaper archives and journal articles
Options
Cancel changes
Follow us:
  • Subscription benefits
  • Log in
  • Sign up for a free, 7-day trial
  • Publications
  • Research topics
  • Topics home
  • People
    • Artists and Entertainers
    • Company executives
    • Historical figures
    • Politicians and Government officials
    • World Leaders
  • Issues and Events
    • Health and Medicine
    • Historical Events
    • Religion and Theology
    • Science and Technology
  • Places
  • Organizations
  • A-Z
    • A-G
    • H-O
    • P-T
    • U-Z
    • 0-9
  • Publications home
  • Journals
    • Academic journals
    • Business journals
    • Education journals
    • Math and Engineering journals
    • Medical journals
    • Science and Technology journals
    • Trade journals
  • Magazines
    • Business magazines
    • Computer magazines
    • Education magazines
    • Industry magazines
    • Lifestyle magazines
    • Medical magazines
  • Newspapers
    • International newspapers and newswires
    • Reports, newsletters, and transcripts
    • U.K. newspapers
    • U.S. newspapers and newswires
  • Reference works and books
    • Almanacs
    • Dictionaries and thesauruses
    • Encyclopedias
    • Non-fiction books
  • Subscription benefits
  • Log in
  • PUBLICATIONS HOME
  • Journals
    • Academic journals
    • Business journals
    • Education journals
    • Math and Engineering journals
    • Medical journals
    • Science and Technology journals
    • Trade journals
  • Magazines
    • Business magazines
    • Computer magazines
    • Education magazines
    • Industry magazines
    • Lifestyle magazines
    • Medical magazines
  • Newspapers
    • International newspapers and newswires
    • Reports, newsletters, and transcripts
    • U.K. newspapers
    • U.S. newspapers and newswires
  • Reference works and books
    • Almanacs
    • Dictionaries and thesauruses
    • Encyclopedias
    • Non-fiction books

Home » Topics » Historical figures » Harry S. Truman » Harry S. Truman: Atomic Bomb

  • Print

Harry S. Truman: Atomic Bomb

By Nadeem Alim For more information, see: Harry S. Truman
  • Permalink

    Create a link to this page

    Copy and paste this link tag into your Web page or blog:

    <a href="https://www.highbeam.com/topics/harry-s-truman-atomic-bomb-t10383" title="Harry Truman: Atomic Bomb - Pictures, News and Articles - HighBeam Research">Harry Truman: Atomic Bomb - Pictures, News and Articles - HighBeam Research</a>

  • RSS

    Your RSS feed has been created

    If your RSS reader did not automatically grab the feed, you can copy and paste the URL below into your RSS reader.

    http://services.highbeam.com/rss/HBR/Harry+S+Truman+Atomic+Bomb?sort=dt&sortdir=d

The Japanese cities have still not fully recovered from the devastation, and for the most part the world fears that if others begin to follow in Harry Truman's footsteps then much greater destruction will follow.

Background

Harry S. Truman succeeded Franklin D. Roosevelt to become the president of the United States on April 12, 1945. He was the U.S. president when the atomic bombs were dropped on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945 and on Nagasaki three days later. Evidence such as Truman's diary reveals that he had not only approved the atomic bombing but also encouraged it, writing that "this weapon is to be used against Japan between now and August 10." An excerpt from the diary written on July 25, 1945 shows that Harry Truman was aware of the immense destructive potential of the atomic bomb before it was used.

"We have discovered the most terrible bomb in the history of the world. It may be the fire destruction prophesied in the Euphrates Valley Era, after Noah and his fabulous Ark." Harry S. Truman, President's Diary, July 25, 1945.

Other statements in Truman's diary are more contradictory to what really happened. For example, referring to the atomic bomb he wrote that the he had ordered to "use it so that military objectives and soldiers and sailors are the target and not women and children." In fact, he went on to write that this was a terrible bomb and hence its "target will be a purely military one." Of course, this was not the case, because Hiroshima and Nagasaki were both civilian cities and the bombs caused many civilian casualties, including women and children. Regardless, Truman stood by his decision and it was mentioned in the following press releases that dropping the bomb had ended World War 2 and saved American lives. At that time, many Americans considered Truman to be a national hero, but various humanitarian debates have spawned since the bombs were dropped, some even accusing Truman of being a war criminal.

Debates on Truman's Decision

The justifications that Harry Truman presented for using the atomic bombs are in fact the main points that are now used to argue against his decision. It seems that the reasons he gave for their use sounded patriotic and virtuous, but the reality of the matter was quite different. For example, in a public paper that the president released on the same day that Hiroshima was bombed he stated, "The Japanese began the war from the air at Pearl Harbor. The have been repaid manifold." Is it accurate to make a comparison between the bombing of Pearl Harbor and the atomic bombing of Hiroshima?

Pearl Harbor was a military base. The purpose of the Japanese bombing was to destroy military aircrafts and demobilize the U.S. Air Force. The Japanese succeeded in their plan, and while there were many casualties, the majority of injuries and fatalities were of military men. In retrospect, Hiroshima and Nagasaki were not military bases. For a large part, these cities consisted of homes, schools and businesses for people of various ages and genders. Despite this fact, Truman made a public statement on August 9, 1945 after the atomic bombing on Nagasaki that states, "Having found the bomb, we have used it. We have used it against those who attacked us without warning at Pearl Harbor, against those who have starved and beaten and executed American prisoners of war, against those who have abandoned all pretense of obeying international laws of warfare." Is it accurate to justify the death of civilians in Hiroshima and Nagasaki as acts of vengeance in response to the bombing of Pearl Harbor?

Perhaps Harry Truman's perception was that all Japanese, including civilians, should be held accountable for the lives lost at Pearl Harbor. To this extent, Truman's statements suggest that Japanese civilians including women and children were part of the same people that "have starved and beaten and executed American prisoners" and should be held responsible. On the other hand, this approach also puts Truman in the position of acknowledging that he intentionally killed women and children instead of just putting them in the category of collateral damages. Is it right to punish a Japanese child for an act of war committed by a Japanese soldier? Japanese generals were executed for war crimes of much lesser scale despite making the same arguments, so it becomes difficult to understand how Harry Truman can be heralded as a war hero instead.

Present Day

During latter years, Harry Truman tried to make rebuttal statements of condolence or further justification. For example, he explained that even though Hiroshima was not a military base it was still an industrial center and hence had military significance. This does not seem to be a valid explanation either, since the U.S. Strategic Bombing Survey states, "All major factories in Hiroshima were on the periphery of the city and escaped serious damage." Other military reports were censored, perhaps to protect the sovereignty of the United States, but of course the grand scale of atomic bombings make them impossible to cover up which is why people have found many reasons to frown upon the atomic bombs that were dropped with orders from Harry Truman in 1945 after seeing the devastating consequences.

Support for Harry Truman and the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki has greatly diminished in recent years. In 1991, President George H. W. Bush claimed that the atomic bombs had "spared millions of American lives." However, this argument has become quite weak since the actual expected American casualties due to World War 2 after August of 1945 is thought to be less than the figures that were presented after the bombs were dropped. The "international laws of warfare" that Truman tried to use as justified explanations condemn his own acts today. Military technology today far exceeds the destructive potential of the atomic bombs that were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The Japanese cities have still not fully recovered from the devastation, and for the most part the world fears that if others begin to follow in Harry Truman's footsteps then much greater destruction will follow.

Read more

Related articles in the news

We're Not 'Globalists,' We're Americans

The Washington Post; March 20, 2018

We're Not 'Globalists,' We're Americans
At one haunted moment in American history - early in 1939, not long after Kristallnacht - Sen. Robert Wagner (D-N.Y.) and Rep. Edith Nourse Rogers (R-Mass.) introduced a bill that would have allowed 20,000 unaccompanied Jewish refugee children into the United States. Opponents argued that Congress…
Trump Is a Modern-Day McCarthy

The Washington Post; February 7, 2018

Trump Is a Modern-Day McCarthy
From time to time, the Republican Party goes off the rails. It did so back in the McCarthy period when it either failed to stand up to the demagogic Wisconsin senator or cheered him on in the name of anti-communism. It did so just recently when it elevated Hillary Clinton from political opponent to…
What Truths about Us Will Future Libraries Hold?

The Washington Post; December 30, 2017

What Truths about Us Will Future Libraries Hold?
"We went to the library on the streetcar. On the streetcar we heard the World Series baseball game. Some of the children were talking and laughing. Some children looked out of the windows. When we got off we walked up the steps and went through a big door. We read and looked at many books. The…
Three Magical Little Words

The Washington Post; December 7, 2017

Three Magical Little Words
A recent whim prompted me to reread Stephen Ambrose's "To America," a collection of reflections on the historian's craft and many of the topics and individuals Ambrose wrote about during his prolific career. The book might have been titled "Second Thoughts," because virtually every chapter…
This Day in History

The Boston Globe (Boston, MA); October 8, 2017

This Day in History
Today's is Sunday, Oct. 8, the 281st day of 2017. There are 84 days left in the year.Birthdays: Entertainment reporter Rona Barrett is 81. Actor Paul Hogan is 78. Rhythm-and-blues singer Fred Cash (The Impressions) is 77. Civil rights activist Rev. Jesse Jackson is 76. Comedian Chevy Chase is 74.…

From the archive

What did Truman know, and when did he know it? (Pres Harry Truman and...

Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists; May 1, 1998

What did Truman know, and when did he know it? (Pres Harry Truman and the atomic bomb)(Brief Article)
The op-ed-style essay on these pages is by Stanley Goldberg, a historian of science, an adviser to the Smithsonian Institution, a frequent contributor to the Bulletin, and a biographer of Gen. Leslie Groves, the man who drove the Manhattan Project to completion. Goldberg died in October of 1996,…
The Crucible of World War II: Harry Truman and the Atomic Bomb

Army; May 1, 2015

The Crucible of World War II: Harry Truman and the Atomic Bomb
The fundamentals of leadership that allow people to do extraordinary things under difficult and trying circumstances are both fascinating and complex. Why do some leaders succeed where others fail? Are leaders born or are they made? Is success a result of coincidence or chance, or is it a byproduct…
Truman's Decision to Drop the Bomb to Be Discussed at 70th Anniversary...

States News Service; July 3, 2013

Truman's Decision to Drop the Bomb to Be Discussed at 70th Anniversary Lecture July 10 Noel Pugach Will Discuss Truman's Decision to Drop Atomic Bombs on Japanese Cities and Explain How and Why He Made It
LOS ALAMOS, New Mexico -- The following information was released by Los Alamos National Laboratory: President Harry S. Truman's decision to use atomic bombs on Japan during World War II will be discussed in the next installment of Los Alamos National Laboratory's 70th Anniversary Public Lecture…
Truman Didn't Hesitate to Drop Atomic Bomb on Japan Series: remembering...

The Washington Post; July 16, 1995

Truman Didn't Hesitate to Drop Atomic Bomb on Japan Series: remembering world war II Series Number: 1/2
Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Blasted by U.S. atomic bombs 50 years ago, the Japanese cities today instantly call to mind images of terrible devastation and the unique horror of history's only nuclear attacks. In 1945, though, they were merely the first two targets in a series of atomic bombings approved…
Prompt and Utter Destruction: President Truman and the Use of Atomic...

Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists; March 1, 1998

Prompt and Utter Destruction: President Truman and the Use of Atomic Bombs Against Japan.
By J. Samuel Walker University of North Carolina, 1997 152 pages; $14.95 Tourists entering the National Air and Space Museum's Enola Gay exhibit in Washington are greeted by an unusually blunt narrative recounting the 1994 firestorm that erupted over what version of history to depict on its walls.…

Find all articles about this topic

Related topics

  • Hiroshima
  • World War II
  • Japan
  • Manhattan Project
  • Company
  • About us
  • Subscription benefits
  • Group subscriptions
  • Careers
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and conditions
  • Contact us
  • Help topics
  • FAQ
  • Search tips
  • Using the Research Center
  • Billing questions
  • Rights inquiries
  • Customer Service
  • Cengage Learning Network
  • Questia
  • CengageBrain.com
  • HighBeam Business
  • ed2go
  • MiLadyPro
  •  
HighBeam Research
Follow us:

HighBeam Research is operated by Cengage Learning. © Copyright 2018. All rights reserved.

The HighBeam advertising network includes: womensforum.com GlamFamily